| 2025 | Jaden Greenwell | Wabash College |
| 2025 | Anders Christianson | Catawba College |
| 2025 | Corbin Deck | Franklin College |
| 2025 | Maguire Gross | Defiance College |
| 2025 | Owen Solis | D'Youville University |
| 2025 | Mason Archer | Catawba College |
| 2025 | Jael DeLa Cruz | Indiana University East |
| 2025 | Ryan Peterson | Northern Kentucky University |
| 2025 | Layne Pogue | Franklin College |
| 2025 | Nick Whitley | Northern Kentucky University |
| 2025 | Chase Alyea | Northern Kentucky University |
| 2025 | Kameron Engle | Defiance College |
| 2025 | Gael Esquada | Saint Mary of the Woods College |
| 2025 | Carlo Huisden | Purdue Fort Wayne |
| 2024 | Jackson Campbell | Saint Mary of the Woods College |
| 2024 | Gavin Hagerty | Wittenburg University |
| 2024 | Wyatt King | Indiana University East |
| 2024 | Tyler Sobieralski | Maryville University |
| 2024 | Ben Hutchinson | Ohio State University |
| 2023 | Jack Hughes | Bethel University |
| 2023 | BawiBawi Thang | Wabash College |
| 2023 | Jacob Irmer | Barton College |
| 2023 | Alex Barkley | King University |
| 2023 | Shad Wilson | Wabash College |
| 2023 | Nick Apostolou | Bethel University |
| 2023 | Jacob Davidson | Dominican University |
| 2023 | Aaron Hanny | lllinois Tech |
| 2023 | Brayden Baxter | Saint Mary of the Woods College |
| 2023 | Andrew Mayer | Purdue Fort Wayne |
| 2023 | Taban Kahre | Thomas More University |
| 2022 | Zach Hayden | North Park University |
| 2022 | Charlie Harr | Lourdes University |
| 2022 | Nolan Bosley | Indiana Tech |
| 2022 | Dylan Poore | Indiana Tech |
| 2022 | Michael Yurk | Wittenburg University |
| 2022 | Connor Davis | North Central College |
| 2021 | Sean Haberthy | King University |
| 2021 | Aaron Hernandez | Ball State University |
| 2021 | Zuri Williams | Fort Valley State University |
| 2021 | Jackson Leeper | Wabash College |
| 2021 | Ashton Seabolt | Webber International University |
| 2021 | Jackson Harvey | Olivet Nazarene University |
| 2021 | Coy Barton | Indiana Tech |
| 2020 | Carson Meadors | Wabash College |
| 2020 | Ricky Sessions | Wabash College |
| 2020 | Milakyi Highsaw | Alderson Broaddus |
| 2020 | Josh Byrne | Indiana Tech |
| 2019 | Garrett Bass | McKendree University |
| 2019 | Zack Anglen | Wentworth Institute of Technology |
| 2019 | Parker Beale | Trine University |
| 2019 | Sam Eiland | St. Xavier University |
| 2019 | Jakob Pickett | Siena Heights University |
| 2018 | Andrew Libby | Clarke University |
| 2018 | David House | Trine University |
| 2017 | Andrew Fitzpatrich | Trinity Christian College |
| 2017 | Solomon Falls | Goshen College |
| 2016 | Dylan Birchell | Campbellsville University |
| 2016 | Rafael Cruz | Campbellsville University |
| 2016 | Keegan Cougil | Campbellsville University |
| 2016 | Keaton Marshall | Campbellsville University |